My fiancé's behavior is making me think

What was your fiancé's reaction time after your ex offered this? If they came directly to you to tell you, what was the reason for that — to close the subject or was it really honesty? Sometimes quick confessions can also be a kind of preemptive strategy.

In this situation with the ex, we can look at it from this angle: It's important how your fiancé presented his role when he was telling you about this proposal. Did he narrate the event in a completely passive way, like "it wasn't my fault, he did it," or did he specifically emphasize how he set boundaries for himself? Because in such situations, whether a person defends themselves based on their position in the event or simply shifts the blame to the other side can make a difference.

Was your fiancé's response direct and clear when the ex-partner made this proposal? Or did they beat around the bush or display indecision? Because sometimes even saying "no" can convey different signals depending on how it's said.

The confusing point is: Is there a consistency between what the fiancé has told and the proposal from the ex? In other words, does it seem like something from the communication with the ex prior to that proposal laid the groundwork for it? Or is it completely a case of "creation from nothing"? This perspective is important because if one is constructing a story, the details provided by the other may remain ambiguous.

When the ex-partner makes this proposal, one must also question whether there has been any impression of "keeping the door open" in the general behavior exhibited by the fiancé up to that moment. Is it only this event that raises doubts, or were the lines clear in the communication with the ex-partner beforehand? Because such a bold proposal usually draws strength from a gap or a mixed signal.

Have you been keeping track of whether you completely cut off your approach to your ex after such a proposal? I mean, if there has been any attempt at "normalizing" the relationship or any attempts at communication afterward, how your fiancé reacted to that would be crucial. What happens after the proposal is just as important.

Do you know what kind of language your ex used when proposing? Was the proposal a straightforward request for a relationship, or was it conveyed through emotional manipulation, like a "favor"? Because the tone of the proposal directly affects how much space the fiancé leaves for him.

I think the ways in which the ex-partner had access to the fiancé before the proposal are just as important as the details of the proposal itself. That is, did they open the communication channel entirely outside of you, or did your fiancé have a direct or indirect role in facilitating their coming together? Because it's not just the emergence of the proposal that matters, but how the opportunity arose tells you much more.

One must consider not only how the fiancé reacted when the ex-partner made this proposal, but also where the ex-partner found the courage to do so. Could it be that there was an unresolved issue between them or a door left ajar? Because in such cases, if one side has completely cut ties, the other side generally wouldn't go this far.

The timing of your ex's offer, aside from that itself, is also interesting regarding when your fiancé chose to tell you about it. Did they share this info right after it happened, or did they explain it because you noticed something and asked? Because the true intentions and stance usually become clearer in the reactions at the moment of sharing.

So did the ex mention anyone else while making this offer, like saying something like "you started it too"? Is there a challenge underlying this offer, or is there a sense of trust regarding your fiancé? Such things usually not only create an emotional void but also generate a mutual dynamic.

Is there an expectation when making a proposal to an ex? It is important to understand that. In other words, did they act with a confidence that suggests their fiancé wouldn’t clearly say "no," or was it purely a case of taking a chance? This distinction shows the clarity of the fiancé's attitude.

What was the feeling your ex-partner experienced at that moment when proposing? Did they talk to you about it openly? Did they react with shock, discomfort, or anger, or did they take a more "I don’t want to confront, but let’s move on" approach? In such proposals, sometimes instead of a clear objection, a passive "let it go" attitude can encourage the other person.

If your fiancé mentioned how he concluded from his ex's actions while narrating this proposal, it's important to understand his perspective. Did he convey that incident just as "he did this, just so you know," or did he express a clear opinion about the ex? The attitude reveals a lot because, in a straightforward narration, there is usually no accountability.

Did your ex make any implications about your fiancé's overall stance when they made this offer? For instance, could they have said something like, "You've always been uncertain" or "You're still leaving the door open for me?" Because if such a sentence was spoken, it might be necessary to question what kind of attitude your fiancé had in the past.

Did you question whether your fiancé conveyed the exact words of the ex's proposal, or did they gloss over some parts? Sometimes, people tend to skip critical details and soften the story. This could be a clue to gauge their sincerity towards you.

When an ex-partner makes such a proposal, the physical distance of your fiancé at that moment is also important; have you ever discussed this? I mean, was the proposal made face-to-face, through a message, or in the presence of someone else? Because if they had the courage to say it face-to-face, there might still be some strange "trust" left between them.

Did you notice how your fiancé positioned themselves while sharing this situation with you? Did they describe the events as completely "I'm innocent, they were weird," or did they also reflect on their own behavior? Generally, people either defend themselves or openly criticize themselves while being at the center of an event; this distinction tells you a lot.

What exactly was your fiancé's response when your ex made the proposal? Did they say a clear "No" or did they give a more vague, uncertain answer? Because in situations like this, the tone and clarity are as important as the words themselves. If you're not sure, I think you should ask detailed questions to uncover anything that seems lacking or unclear.

I found the timing of this offer from your ex to be strange. If they are doing something like this knowing your fiancé's relationship status, either the past chapters have never really closed, or there is still some passive communication between them. Did you ask your fiancé about this; could there be an unresolved issue that was left open between them?

The roles are important in breaking up with an ex. If your fiancé was the one to initiate the separation, it's no surprise that the other party still harbors hope. However, the ex finding the courage to make a proposal may indicate that your fiancé hasn't clearly defined their boundaries. Therefore, the real question to ask is: How has your fiancé been describing their place in their past relationship up to now? Was it a sudden proposal that came out of nowhere, or is it a result of ambiguities left unaddressed in the past?

Was it discussed how your ex mentioned your fiancé's relationship when making this proposal? Did they clearly draw a line like, "I'm engaged, let's put an end to this," or was the atmosphere more personal without emphasizing the relationship? I think how they reflected your relationship to the other person is an important detail.

I was just curious about this: Did your fiancé have any other contact with his ex besides this proposal? I mean, did this situation just explode out of nowhere, or was there some groundwork for the idea of "I’ll try this"? Because it sounds ridiculous for such a proposal to come out of the blue.

Have you thought about what your fiancé's purpose was in telling you about this incident? Did he say it because he wanted you to know, or was there another reason? Some people try to share the burden instead of taking responsibility; this detail could be important.

Did you notice any hesitation or tension on your fiancé's face or body language while they were talking? Some people brush over the topic casually, while others speak about it with genuine ease. Which one was it? Because the emotional intensity of this situation could offer the most clues about your fiancé's intentions and feelings.

Do you think your fiancé might have predicted how you would react when they talked about this incident? I mean, did they share it because they trust you and felt relieved, or did they think "you would find out anyway"? There's a difference between the two; one is honesty, the other is necessity.

Did your fiancé tell you about your ex's proposal, or did you find out and talk to him? Because if he brought it up himself, that's an honest step, but if he confessed it when you asked, there’s a serious difference between the two. The initial intent matters.

When an ex offers this, it's worth considering not only how the fiancé disregards the relationship status but also questioning the fiancé's first reaction to this offer. Did they respond directly and dismissively, or was there a moment of reflection or hesitation first? Because the dialogue established at that moment speaks volumes more than the offer itself.

It's strange for an ex to make such a proposal, but the content of the proposal is more important. Was it something like "let's try again," or was it a detailed and expectation-filled confession? Because for someone to do this suggests that there might have been some experiences that made them feel there isn't still a red line in the past. Is the explanation from the fiancée clear on this part?

It's natural for this event to make you think, but you also need to question why your ex is making such an offer: "Is it because of the openness my fiancé showed in the past?" Even if your fiancé has set clear boundaries, why does that woman still find the courage to do this? I think the communication dynamic from the past is now more critical.

The timing of your fiancé's reaction to the proposal is just as important as the content of the proposal itself. In other words, when they told you about their ex suggesting something like that—was it immediate, or did they wait a while? If there was a delay, you need to understand why they waited, because it draws a line between honesty and a delayed explanation.

So, was the ex aware of your fiancé's current relationship when making this proposal? Did your fiancé clearly state, "I'm engaged," to clarify the situation, or did the other party come forward despite this information? Because sometimes the issue isn't the proposal itself, but rather how clearly each party shows where they stand.

I think the real question is this: How did your fiancé express his position while explaining this offer to you? Did he just explain what happened or did he clearly state something like "I will not accept these kinds of things no matter what"? Because if it's a passive narration, it’s unclear how determined your fiancé is in such situations.

So how did you realize if there were any missing details in the way your fiancé narrated the answer he gave to his ex's proposal? I mean, do you think he could have made a "selection" between what he recounted and what actually happened? Because sometimes people tell the truth, but they tell it incompletely; those missing pieces can change the story completely.

Do you know about this incident based on what your fiancé told you, or did you hear it from another source? If this information came from somewhere other than your fiancé's explanation, I think it means that not only is your fiancé's reaction process in question, but your sense of trust is also being challenged. Are you currently going back and forth in your mind, thinking, "What else was I not told about this?"

It's actually important to understand whether your fiancée feels any emotional burden at the moment of the proposal. In other words, did the ex feel guilt, nostalgia, or an attempt to form a connection when making this proposal? Because such "old ties" can affect the tone people use when making explanations. It's not enough for your fiancée to simply say "I rejected it"; I would say pay close attention to how she says it.

Did they have any contact before this proposal with their ex? I mean, did this offer come out of nowhere, or was there some communication, messaging, or an existing connection from the past? Because it feels odd to boldly say something like this out of the blue.

Did your fiancé's attitude towards this person change after the ex's proposal, meaning did they put up completely some distance? Or do they still maintain communication in any way, saying that they rejected the proposal? Because the real test should be the attitude displayed after this proposal.

So how do we know how much information your ex has about your fiancé's current situation when making this offer? I mean, do you trust only what your fiancé has told you, or have you had a chance to confirm it from another source? Because sometimes the version being told can use "the other party's ignorance" as a shield.

Did your fiancé have a boundary conversation with their ex after this incident? I think it's important to not only reject but also to understand that an old bond must be completely severed. Because if there's still a door left open for old stories after such offers, that's where the trouble begins.

I suggest you think about what might be behind an ex's proposal like this. I mean, your fiancé may have given a clear answer in their own way, but the fact that the other person was still able to show this courage raises the question, "Was there ever a glimmer of hope in the past?" Is this offer completely an absurd move, or is it an extension of past communication?

I thought about how your fiancé told you about the incident after receiving the offer from their ex. Did they bring it up without you asking, or did you somehow find out and then discuss it? If they mentioned it on their own, it might be a sign of honesty; however, did this revelation come after you confirmed something else? Because this difference can change a lot in terms of reading intentions.

What bothers me more is whether the ex-lover made this proposal knowing full well the current situation of the fiancée. If that's the case, it might indicate that the boundaries were not clear in the past. Because if there's a healthy breakup, no one would muster such courage.

The strangest thing to me here is the way your fiancé described this event to you. I mean, what specific details did they give, and did you sense any kind of "writing their own narrative" in the places they chose to explain? Because sometimes, with the mask of "I'm being honest with you," they leave out crucial parts. Maybe they're not hiding anything, but omitting information is also a form of manipulation.

The fact that his ex-girlfriend is coming up with such a proposal actually shows his perception of your fiancé. Has your fiancé set a clear boundary, or if the other party still dares to approach knowing the "special situation," then we need to dig a little deeper here. Otherwise, has some kind of blurry area been left somewhere?

Let's assume that your fiancé is still in contact with his ex after the proposal was rejected. In that case, it's important to understand the motivation behind your fiancé maintaining this connection. If the relationship is completely over, does the ex's ability to still have space suggest that your fiancé is not being consistent in his behavior? Perhaps from the ex's perspective, the rejection of the proposal may not have been perceived as a definite end.

So do you think your ex's proposal had an emotional impact on your fiancé? I mean, did they just brush it off with a "I rejected it, it's over" attitude, or did they consider how this proposal would affect you and take an extra step? Because sometimes the issue isn't just about drawing the line, but also about valuing your partner's feelings regarding the situation and acting accordingly.

Even if we assume that the ex is completely out of the fiancé's life after this offer, the timing and manner in which the fiancé communicates this situation to you is still important. Do you think just rejecting it is sufficient? In other words, was there a sense of being "forced into knowledge" regarding this situation, or did it come across as a natural sharing? I think the real confusion starts here.

Do you know in what context your fiancé talked to his ex after this proposal? For instance, has he shown any stance beyond just rejecting her? If there wasn't a closure like "Let's not talk anymore, there's no need," that would mean leaving the door open for the other person. If there is a clear end, I would think your fiancé would want you to see that.

It's not so much that the ex is still finding a way after the proposal, but rather what kind of impression the communication built in the past by the fiancé before that proposal might have left? Did this proposal come out of nowhere or were there hints left open? I think that's where the main root lies.

So how did the ex find the courage to propose in that environment? Was there communication after the relationship ended, or were there things left unresolved with the fiancé from the past? Because sometimes people say, "I could sense what the other person was feeling, so it seems I saw an open door after all." This needs to be clarified; otherwise, the story remains incomplete.

You say that they rejected the offer, but I think anyone who sees that the other party has no boundaries in such a situation would not take that person back into their life. If the rejection wasn't enough, why wasn't there a more definitive process of communication cut-off? This seems a bit confusing to me.

Is this offer something your fiancé told you or did you find out in another way? Because if they shared it themselves, they may really believe they have set a boundary, but if they didn't say anything, the motivation to keep it secret raises another suspicion in my opinion. This detail is important.

It's one thing that she rejected the proposal, but how clear was your fiancé's stance at that point? Saying "I rejected it" is part of it, but did the ex still muster the courage to stay in touch after making that proposal? This question might need to be directed at your fiancé, because if she says "it's not about me" and completely withdraws, that seems a bit like an easy way out.

It's important to consider the impression your ex gave when making this proposal. In other words, did they just reject it, or did they really draw the line with "you have no place in my life"? Or is there a gray area such as "I'm engaged, but I can still be friends with you"? Clarity is everything in such situations.

So what is the timing of your ex's proposal? Did they act knowing that you were in your fiancée's life, or did this happen at an earlier point? Because such courage to interfere in someone's life can sometimes stem from a "weak" signal from the other party.

If coming up with such a proposal from an ex is a matter of courage, could it be that this courage was found simply because the previous relationship "didn't end happily"? In other words, could it be less about your fiancé not giving a clear signal here, and more about the other side having a motivation to piece things together or to finish what was left unfinished? Because sometimes, people who have a hard time accepting that "it's really over" may make such attempts just for their own peace of mind.

The motivation of the ex is understandable to some extent, perhaps, but I think the attitude of your fiancé is more important. We can call it "honest" because they shared it with you, but does this honesty serve as a relief, or is it solution-oriented? Because sometimes people want to clearly state something and shift responsibility off of themselves, but they may not show the same clarity in their actions.

The process leading up to the proposal with the ex is actually important. So, we only know the moment of the proposal, but what kind of communication was there before that? It doesn't seem like there was just a sudden outburst from nowhere; they either received a signal or saw a gap. You need to discuss this with your fiancé and learn about the entire process that took place in between. "I rejected the proposal" isn't enough. What happened until that point?

Is the ex still bold even after your fiancé "rejected" this offer? If there's a situation that doesn't close with a single rejection, then the fiancé's reactions can be questioned as well. Because sometimes people say "no" but still leave the door ajar. If you're saying this, I think you should ask your fiancé directly: has he really burned all the bridges?

This is also confusing: Did they come to you to explain the offer they rejected, or did it come up because you asked? If they didn't share it on their own, it raises some questions about their honesty, regardless of their intentions. Just think, if you hadn't warned them, you might never have found out.

Are we currently assessing the ex as a fiancé? The guy has made the proposal, okay. But it comes back to the fiancé, asking, "Why am I still carrying this as an issue?" If the proposal didn't end with a rejection, then who is signaling the problem?

So did you get in touch again after your ex's proposal? I mean, was all communication cut off completely, or did "friendly" messages continue afterward? Because in situations like this, just rejecting isn't enough; you need to consider what happens next.

Did the ex entirely withdraw, stopping at "the offer was rejected"? I mean, is this someone who really stepped off the stage, or are they thinking "maybe time will pass and I’ll try again"? It's important to understand if your fiancé has completely reset the communication here. If you said "no" but there were things like "maybe we can check in once in a while," that's a bad signal coming from there.

Your ex-fiancé must have drawn this courage from somewhere. She says she rejected the proposal, but was there any contact between them before that proposal, or did it just emerge as a reckoning of the past? Even if it's the latter, your fiancé's reaction shouldn't just be about "rejecting" it, but should have involved questioning why that past resurfaced. Did you ask her about this aspect?

I have one question: Did someone from your fiancé's circle support this old lover's courage? A mutual friend, a companion, an intermediary... Sometimes such bold actions occur when the ground is prepared, and the background can include such connections. Have you ever looked into the dynamics of that environment?

Did the ex know the fiancé's relationship status for sure? Sometimes people think things are unclear when proposing, feeling a sense of "maybe." It's also worth questioning how the fiancé expressed the seriousness of their relationship to the other party. Did you discuss this side?

Why did the ex still have hope even if he was aware of your fiancé's current relationship when making this offer? Wasn't a single "no" enough for him to back off? And how long after did your fiancé tell you about this? How much did this incident linger in his mind during that time? The emotional state is also significant here.

When your ex makes this suggestion, the attitude of your fiancé is important, but the surroundings of the ex are also significant. Did this person make a completely independent move, or did they act in an environment where they still see the fiancé as "accessible"? Because simply saying "no" to cut ties with the past is not always enough; if there are still those who see a door ajar in the surroundings, that’s where the real problem starts. Have you ever been able to talk about this with your fiancé?

You say your fiancée both rejected and explained, but you haven’t clarified the details at all. When she rejected you, did she show her discomfort, or did she act "politely"? In situations like these, even the tone can signal whether the other person intends to continue or not. Did you ask her about that?

It's nice that you're talking about what you're feeling, but do you think this "talking" is truly to relax you, or is it more to ease your conscience? Sometimes people are honest in what they say, but their behavior conveys something else. Can you be clear about your feelings?

After the proposal, did the ex completely withdraw, or is that a bit unclear? I mean, are there still situations like "meeting, messaging, running into each other," or is it just the proposal and rejection left from that relationship? It's hard to understand whether your fiancé has reacted without knowing this clearly.

Let's assume that the ex had made an offer knowing the status of his ex-fiancé; then it becomes important whether the fiancé clarified the boundaries of the relationship to the other party. So, the proposal was rejected, but did this rejection send the message of "don't do something like this again" to the other party? Or did the issue close, but the ambiguity or softness left a hidden door?

If the ex-partner proposed knowing about the fiancé's situation, the timing of the fiancé telling you about it could also be an important clue. Was the proposal conveyed to you immediately, or was there a waiting period in between? If they kept it a secret for a while, I think it should also be questioned why they felt the need to hide it.

So how is the boundary with your fiancé's ex? I mean, if there was communication between them before this proposal issue, that proposal might have grown in that context. Is the past really completely closed, or is there an "old bond" that has been overlooked?

I think it's also important to consider whether your ex has found an opportunity to show some courage with your fiancé after the proposal. So, has it completely ended, or was there an attempt to "check in" again after that rejection? Because sometimes, certain rejections don't stop the other person; they just lead to a change in strategy. Even if nothing explicit happened in this regard, your fiancé's attitude is crucial.

There's so much focus on the ex's proposal, but have you thought about your fiancé's own ties to the past? Did it become completely clear when the proposal came, or were those ties already closed off in some way? Because sometimes people say it's "over," but when you dig a little, there's actually an emotional wreckage left behind. Has this been talked about?

Forget about the ex's proposal for a moment; did you pay attention to the tone and level of detail your fiancé used when explaining this situation to you? In other words, was this narrative a sort of relaxation tool, or was it genuinely intended to keep you in the loop? Because there's a difference between "keeping someone informed" and "getting their opinion in an equal context." Which one was it?

It's also important whether your fiancé talked about their own feelings while narrating. Did they just convey the situation by saying "it's over, it's closed," or did they express their own feelings, surprise, discomfort, or reactions regarding this proposal? If they didn't share their feelings while telling it, I would say, how firm does that rejection seem?

Rejecting an ex's proposal may not be the same as your fiancé completely ending the dynamics of their relationship with that person. Just because they have "rejected the proposal" doesn’t eliminate the doubt that a bond still exists. Are you evaluating your fiancé's relationship with this person merely on a "surface" level? Are you sure there isn’t a deeper connection that remains in the past?

Is there a "sequence of realization" in your fiancé communicating this situation to you? I mean, did the ex make a proposal, your fiancé reject it, and then after a few days, did they share it? Or did they share it right away? Because some people narrate events immediately, while others gauge their reaction in their mind first. If there's a part where they gauge their reaction, they might be looking out for themselves more than protecting you.

The issue is not just that they rejected the proposal, but also their current distance and relationship dynamics with the ex-partner. Do they still feel the need to keep them in their life at some point? For instance, is there still a connection on social media? Old records might continue to be opened from there. Without discussing these details, it won't become clear.

Besides the ex trying to find a connection in the fiancé's life after the proposal, the clarity the fiancé currently shows towards the ex is also significant. For instance, rejecting the proposal is one thing, but it's another if the fiancé doesn't put some distance between them afterward. Is the ex still trying to normalize things, and how is the fiancé reacting to that? If you don't clarify this part, just saying "rejection" isn't enough.

The reactions of your fiancé to their ex's proposal can be as thought-provoking as their comments about how this proposal affected your relationship together. In other words, did they make an effort to reassure you while sharing this situation and demonstrate their sincerity, or did you feel more of a sense of "obligation"? Because sometimes, people might just be concerned about relieving themselves of a responsibility.

The point I'm stuck on is this: where did the ex find the courage to make a proposal? I mean, did the fiancée give the impression of being completely "closed" in previous communications? Because some people don't make such risky moves without seeing an open door. Was there a gray area left there, or was there any conversation about this?

I think it would be clearer for you to stop talking about your ex and focus on the overall behavior and attitude of your fiancé. Otherwise, you'll tire yourself out with old issues. Right now, how is he behaving towards you and your relationship? If there's a problem there, that's the real issue.

If an ex is proposing, I would immediately question how clear my fiancé was in their previous relationship. It's not just about rejecting the proposal; it requires openly discussing any potential feelings of "being caught in the middle" that could have led to this proposal. If they say, "I already ended it a long time ago," then it's important to ask how that ending happened: Was it a clean break or left ambiguous?

Have you ever wanted to ask someone to completely cut off communication with their ex? Some people continue to think in the mindset of "we can be friends" unless it is explicitly stated otherwise. Could you have been lacking in setting those boundaries from the beginning?

Did anything troubling happen after the ex's proposal to the fiancé? I mean, did this person try to reach out again or cause any disturbances in another way? Because just as it's important for the fiancé to set boundaries, it's also crucial whether these boundaries are accepted by the other party. If there's still an issue, a more active approach might be necessary.

How much do you trust your fiancé's way of explaining this situation to you? Did you learn about it directly, or did you find out through their explanation? Because sometimes, when recounting events, there can be a tendency to hide their own part of the story; I suggest you don't overlook that possibility.

Has your fiancé been uncomfortable with the offer from your ex? Has he said anything about it? Some may dismiss it, but they don’t take the seriousness of the situation very seriously; they brush it off as "such things happen." It's also important to understand how serious this offer has been for him. What is his perception like?

Did your fiancé share this reaction with you when they first heard it, or did you have to sense something and pursue it? Because I believe the real intention and feeling are revealed more in the reflexes at that moment than in the event itself. Did they panic, go into defense mode, or were they relaxed? These things don't go unnoticed.

Putting aside the courage of the ex to make a proposal, it's also significant that your fiancé chose the person who informed him of this news. The situation with the ex is over, fine, but is this someone who still has a chance to enter and exit your life, that they are telling him this instead of you? Have you considered it from this angle?

I think it's a separate issue that this ex has still access to the fiancé's circle. In other words, we need to consider not only the fiancé's attitude but also how much the surrounding people allowed this situation. Even if the guy shuts himself off, is there someone around him who leaves the doors ajar?

It's not so much a matter of courage when an ex proposes, but rather a matter of context. "Did this person think they could somehow get a positive response when making this proposal?" That's the question you should be looking to answer. Could your fiancé's stance still be unclear enough to leave doubts in your ex's mind? I think it's worth questioning the likelihood of excessive tolerance or the possibility of having managed things without completely cutting ties.

Where do you think your ex's fiancé found the courage to test the boundaries? Normally, when it’s over, the other person hesitates to make a proposal, feeling completely disconnected. Here, either a clear "it's over" message wasn't conveyed in the past, or there may be a sense of "emptiness" in the fiancé's behavior. If such gaps exist, do you think the fiancé is aware of them? Is their mind completely at ease?

Who initiated communication with the ex? Was there a conversation between them before this proposal? Did this proposal come out of nowhere, or was there some subtle probing beforehand? Because it is generally not entirely a "coincidence" when such things happen.

But did the ex do this proposal knowing that your fiancé is engaged? Some people can act to provoke intentionally. Or is there another misunderstanding, are you speaking with certainty?

Could the ex's making this offer also be related to their own personal dynamics, independent of the messages sent by their fiancé? In other words, could it not be simply due to a perception of emptiness, but rather a scenario where "no" has no meaning for that person, and they are acting based on their own feelings? Because sometimes, rather than the expectations of the other party, there is a bravery trapped in the ex's own world. Have you ever considered this possibility?

Well, didn't the timing of this proposal seem strange to you at all? Do you think it's just a coincidence that it came up at a stage when relationships, like engagement periods, become more defined? Sometimes people take such steps not just to manipulate the past, but the future as well. Could your ex's move have the intention of provoking you instead of targeting your fiancé?