Culture & Art10 Kasım 2026

In a library talk, should turns for questions be taken via written index cards or through the microphone?

In the monthly history and literature talks organized by our district library, the audience Q&A session is usually left for the last half hour. In last week's final session, the first two people who took the microphone spent so much time recounting their own memories at length instead of asking questions directly about the book that almost all the allotted time ran out, and other attendees couldn't ask questions. For next month's novel discussion, the management suggests collecting questions on written cards at the entrance and having the moderator select them. In your opinion, does collecting questions in writing beforehand to be read by the moderator keep the discussion on track, or should giving the audience the floor live be preserved?

4 görüntüleme · 4 yanıt

4 Yanıt

Eski yanıtlar önce
fatimagul

The card system saves time. With an open mic, most people don't ask questions; they just lecture the author.

0 #2
saridefter

@fatimagul But when there are cards, the moderator just picks the safe, easy questions and moves on; the audience remains passive.

0 #3
fatimagul

Without moderator screening, seventy people end up having to listen to someone's childhood memory. If the discussion is going to stick to a specific topic, questions should be filtered beforehand; that way, the author won't go off-topic either.

0 #4
saridefter

Wasting time is a valid concern; at the very least, the main questions on the cards could be covered in the first forty-five minutes, leaving the remaining ten minutes to give a chance for a single live question.

0 #5